Undisputed borders as criteria for recognition

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Follow Up ] [ UCLA Open Forum ]

Posted by DSCBruin on April 22, 2024 at 16:50:20

In Reply to: A standard criteria for recognition is . . . posted by BluBlood on April 22, 2024 at 13:44:24

Why was Israel recognized? The UN partitions were decided with no input from the Arabs.

Today, Israel is demolishing homes in the West Bank and building settlements. Can the "undisputed" thing be just one-sided? Israel doesn't dispute the settlements, and therefore Israel recognized!

Follow Ups:

If Palestine has no clear borders, neither does Israel blindness 16:58:45 04/22/24 (10)
- Israel's strategy is to keep the borders disputed DSCBruin 10:19:59 04/23/24 (1)
  - They also perpetually undermine emerging Palestinian blindness 11:05:27 04/23/24 (0)
- Re: If Palestine has no clear borders, neither does Israel Dr.J 17:26:43 04/22/24 (7)
  - So they’re doing what Russia is doing with Ukraine, I guess* Fuzzy 17:52:30 04/22/24 (1)
    - Re: So they’re doing what Russia is doing with Ukraine, I guess* Dr.J 18:30:11 04/22/24 (0)
  - I am guessing the operative word in Blu's post blindness 17:51:50 04/22/24 (4)
    - The borders are clear enough but not acceptable to extremists Dr.J 18:38:41 04/22/24 (3)
      - From the river to the sea.... blindness 20:05:58 04/22/24 (1)
        
        I think that is Netanyahu’s embrace of extremism Dr.J 20:21:13 04/22/24 (0)
      - Another extremist element DSCBruin 19:39:59 04/22/24 (0)
A UN resolution partitioned Britain’s mandate in Palestine Dr.J 16:58:40 04/22/24 (7)
- Despite settlements, Israel stays recognized DSCBruin 17:04:36 04/22/24 (6)
  - Re: Despite settlements, Israel stays recognized Dr.J 17:25:27 04/22/24 (5)
    - True, but there is a lot of evidence that DSCBruin 18:24:30 04/22/24 (4)
      - At what point did Israel become horrible? * ClockBlocker 22:51:51 04/22/24 (3)
        
        An official line is usually drawn at the failure of 2000 blindness 09:23:58 04/23/24 (0)
        
        When the West Bank stopped being occupation and instead . . BluBlood 07:57:49 04/23/24 (0)
        
        Netanyahu in power DSCBruin 00:45:37 04/23/24 (0)

Post a Followup