In Reply to: How many of those guys had good nfl careers? posted by ClockBlocker on May 28, 2025 at 21:25:21
They were exceptional college players, probably in the top 1% of performers. We aren't concerned with what they did before college (high school) or after college. We're only concerned with what they did while in college. And in that, they were excellent.
The NFL comparison is bogus.
Using the NFL standard, you'd have to conclude Gary Beban wasn't a very good college player and that Tom Brady was the best college player of all time.
This is a sloppy mental process. It isn't thinking.